You may recall our recent discussion of HR1506, the Markey-Platts bill that would increase average fuel efficiency standards to 35MPG in ten years.
Republicans are apparently too beholden to the energy cartels to even consider such a modest step (it ought to be 50MPG in five years).
Rep. Duncan's office responds to our communication re. the bill with a form letter position paper (PDF copy attached):
I agree we need to protect our environment, however, there have also been some unintended consequences resulting from these standards. In fact, according to data published in 1991 by the Office of Technology Assessment, "A 40 percent increase in fuel economy standards would reduce greenhouse emissions by only about 0.5 percent, even under the most optimistic assumptions."This is due in part to the fact that cars and light trucks subject to fuel economy standards make up only 1.5 per-cent of all global man-made greenhouse gas emissions.
Support for increasing CAFE standards for environmental reasons seems to be based more on rhetoric and a desire to increase federal regulation than sound scientific efforts to reduce pollution.
So many distortions, so little time.
Start with "cars and light trucks subject to fuel economy standards." There's a giant loophole you can drive a Hummer through for Big Manly Pickups and SUVs built on "light truck" frames which are subject to lower CAFE standards (which is why there are so many SUVs and Minivans on the road). HR1506 would apply to all vehicles up to 10,000 pounds.
Further, 1.5 percent of global emissions is a pretty huge number, if you think about it in relative terms of encompassing only US cars and light trucks mostly used for personal transportation. But at least Rep. Duncan admits there is such a thing as greenhouse gas emissions, and concedes that some are man-made.
But what about all the other economic and environmental and foreign policy benefits of reducing consumption, reducing pollution, and reducing dependence on foreign oil? Are these the "unintended consequences" Rep. Duncan wishes to avoid?
|
Topics:
|
|
Discussing:
- Federal Government sending marketing (campaign) messages? (1 reply)
- Knox SOUP Announces New Name, November 5 Community Dinner, and Call for Project Proposals (1 reply)
- Oconaluftee, Cherokee, Newfound Gap (1 reply)
- Pedestrians be careful, drivers (and pedestrians) not attentive (3 replies)
- Check and Recheck your ballot when voting (5 replies)
- Bernie Sanders vs AI (1 reply)
- SoKno discombobulation continues (2 replies)
- Execution failed!!! (3 replies)
- GOP Senator "deserves the obloquy" (2 replies)
- AI company going public says "existential risks to humanity" (2 replies)
- Michaela Barnett for Congress TN-02 (2 replies)
- Timing is everything (2 replies)
Upcoming events:
- Nov 5 2026 - 5:30pm (1 day 9 hours from now)
TN Progressive
- Blount County pausing on housing growth? (BlountViews)
- Tues., Oct. 20, 2026, Free Flu Shots at Blount County Health Dept. (BlountViews)
- View from the Overlook (Whitescreek Journal)
- Alcoa property taxes will probably not go up (BlountViews)
- Smith & Wesson not a good fit for Blount County (BlountViews)
- WATCH THIS SPACE. (Left Wing Cracker)
- America As It Is Right Now (RoaneViews)
- A friend sent this: From Captain McElwee's Tall Tales of Roane County (RoaneViews)
- The Meidas Touch (RoaneViews)
- Massive Security Breach Analysis (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
TN Politics
- ‘Not the end of the fight’: Green strikes positive tone in concession to Blackburn (TN Lookout)
- The blue tsunami sweeps the US, as Democrats land huge gains in Congress (TN Lookout)
- Victoria Broderick claims victory over U.S. Rep. Scott DesJarlais in 4th Congressional District (TN Lookout)
- Democrats score control of US Senate in stunning midterm victory (TN Lookout)
- Republican Brent Taylor claims victory; Justin Pearson does not concede US House race (TN Lookout)
- Republican Charlie Hatcher defeats Molder to win Tennessee’s 5th Congressional District (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- East Tennessee voters decide key races in 2026 general election (Knox TN Today)
- Let’s Talk: Youth — Safer streets, reading success and brighter futures (and Vols win) (Knox TN Today)
- The Book Whisperer recommends an Anthology of Tree Stories (Knox TN Today)
- 10 reasons to read KnoxTNToday (and one reason you might regret it) (Knox TN Today)
- Young Readers’ Shelf: Different stories, shared humanity (Knox TN Today)
- Know a young hero? Hero Kid nominations close November 30 (Knox TN Today)
- Fulton Falcons finish season with flurry of wins to sneak into Class 4A playoffs (Knox TN Today)
- First-generation Pellissippi State students carry dreams bigger than themselves (Knox TN Today)
- Mama Said: “You let the cat out of the bag!” (Knox TN Today)
- High School Sports Roundup: Soccer season closes as runners prepare for state championships (Knox TN Today)
- Let’s Talk: Neighbors — Election Day, helping hands and neighborhood pride (Knox TN Today)
- Lady Vols take season opener against Dukes (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Senator Bill Hagerty reelected in Tennessee (WATE)
- Tim Burchett wins reelection to Tennessee’s 2nd Congressional District (WATE)
- Knoxville voters approve amendment streamlining city council elections (WATE)
- Republican Chuck Fleischmann wins reelection for Tennessee's District 3 US House seat (WATE)
- Democrat Bryan Goldberg unseats Knoxville Rep. Elaine Davis in House District 18 (WATE)
- Man injured after stabbing near LaFollette (WATE)
News Sentinel
State News
- Chattanooga Times Free Press printing moves to Knoxville News Sentinel - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Fleischmann wins reelection but loses Hamilton County to Golladay - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Chattanooga Democrats cheer election gains as statewide races remain uncertain - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Hamilton County state House, Senate incumbents reelected - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Dow futures rally 700 points as Democrats win big in midterms: Live updates - CNBC (Business)
- Voters punish Trump with historic swing to Democrats - The Washington Post (US News)
- Democrats deliver a stunning rout in Texas to retake power for the first time in decades - AP News (US News)
- GOP Sen. Pete Ricketts fends off independent Dan Osborn in Nebraska Senate race - NBC News (US News)
- Oil Prices Fall as Investors Weigh U.S. Midterm Results, Iran Risks - WSJ (Business)
- Democrat Gina Hinojosa defeats Texas governor Greg Abbott in stunning upset - The Guardian (US News)
- El-Sayed defeats Rogers to win Michigan Senate race - The Hill (US News)
- See 2026 Texas midterm election results from key local races - CBS News (US News)
- Supermarket Chain Thaw Massacre: Russia suspected in Europe’s fridge attacks - POLITICO.eu (Business)
- Melat Kiros becomes the first Gen Z woman elected to Congress - NPR (US News)
- China's services growth slows to three-month low as confidence weakens - Reuters (Business)
- How malware and a bogus job interview let attackers nab $6.3B from Binance - The Washington Post (Business)
- Key Part of Jet in Deadly Florida Crash Found Far From Impact Site - The New York Times (US News)
- Google Curbs AI in School Accounts After Pushback - WSJ (Business)
- Nvidia and other Big Tech stocks lift the US market despite drops for Apple and much of Wall Street - AP News (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South

reducing dependence on
reducing dependence on foreign oil?
A key element, not to be forgotten.
Do You
give Congressman Duncan any credit for voting in the affirmative for the Clean Air Act Ammendments in 1990? or Do you just like to bash Republicans? The answers could be yes to both questions.
Have Great Evening.
I would give him more credit
I would give him more credit if he held TVA to it, and worked in Congress to uphold the new source review provisions that Bush rolled back.
P.S. I voted for Duncan
P.S. I voted for Duncan several times. But thanks for reminding me why I won't vote for him again. Nice work for the party there, my good friend.
Well, I am happy
to help a Democrat find his way. so, You are welcome.
BTW, can you tell me when Tennessee's Second Congressional District has last been represented by a Democrat?
BTW, can you tell me when
BTW, can you tell me when Tennessee's Second Congressional District has last been represented by a Democrat?
Please stay on topic.
Well, now Rachel
I beilieved it was on topic when Randy said he wasn't going to vote for Duncan again and a reference to voting against a Republican.
However, if it wasn't on topic, I apologize and beg for forgiveness.
Have a great evening.
Like so many Repugs, Duncan
Like so many Repugs, Duncan claims that of course, there needs to be a "balance" between legislation benefiting the environment and that benefiting the "economy" (as if it's an either/or, and it often isn't). Thing is, I've never seen an either/or type bill where he "balanced" any of his pro-business votes with even one vote for the environment. Not one. Sure, maybe he occasionally throws a token environmental bone, but not if it's not already a slam dunk or if it conflicts with big business. I'd love someone else to fact-check this for us. Maybe someone on Brian's staff could help.
Besides, when are Repugs going to learn that there is all the job and technology growth to be gained by investing in clean technologies of tomorrow, not the dirty, low tech plundering of the past? Fossil fuels and nuclear are for dying economies that keep falling behind. Only the fat cats can keep making money off them.
And what has Jimmy done for the polluted Smokies and the endless maintenance backlog of lost budget funds? Lifting a finger while the GOP had control of Congress would have been a good time to support his constituents' region.
No wonder Duncan gets near zero grades from environmental organizations.
< / rant>
I wonder when he decided that climate change and man-made CO2 contributions to it are even real, and what convinced him?
Have a wonderful evening.
I think Duncan is weaseling
He quotes a report from 1991 and then refers to vehicles subject to the cafe standards. One of the problems with the way the standards are applied is that "light trucks" don't fall under the more stringent requirements. This is why I've switched from my beloved Subaru's to my 34 mpg Matrix. I'd like to do a bit of research on that. (Can I get a copy of Duncan's letter? update: Duh...I see the attachment, sorry)
Anyway, Duncan may be one of the more lucid republicans but he's still an ideologue and quite destructive in his overall environmental votes.
Thanks for your letter, Randy. sounds like folks need to send him another one.
Steve
Duncan is like a broken clock
He's right exactly twice a day: first, on the Iraq "war" in the AM and, second, on the Iraq "war" in the PM. Otherwise, his hands don't really move (except to pocket bribes [aka "campaign contributions"] from bidness interests).