I wrote my first opinion column when I was in high school, fifty years ago. Guest columns have been part of my career from collegiate days at Penn State, Syracuse, and Ohio University to teaching jobs in Cincinnati, Texas, and Knoxville, Tennessee.
Along the way I’ve picked up several honors for column writing, including two prestigious Sigma Delta Chi awards. I write this not to brag, but to establish credentials for evaluating the state of opinion writing.
It’s not good. The practitioners at some of our largest newspapers are as good as ever, but the bench of opinion writers at other publications dwindles daily. Newspaper chains have dropped many paid local columnists—relying instead on handout material and letting it linger on the front directory pages of news sites for days or even weeks.
continued...
Our country now has news deserts, places where there is no local daily newspaper or news site. Even where such things remain, they are shells of their former selves. Coverage of local governing bodies is missing. Puff pieces abound. Hard copy opinion pages may occur only two or three times a week. Academia has followed suit; the number of opinion journalism courses has shrunk dramatically.
For many years at the University of Tennessee, I created and volunteered to teach a one-credit, pass-fail course called “How to Argue Without Yelling or Punching.” The course guided freshmen through some of the basics of crafting an argument—finding supporting information, catching and rebutting logical fallacies. It concluded with students facing off in Lincoln-Douglas style debates.
The students liked the course almost as much as I did. It was a delight to see them critically analyzing claims, discovering the strengths and weaknesses of arguments, and being honest enough to judge whether a person did a good job of arguing, even if that person presented a view opposite to your own.
We aren’t in a time of reading or listening to one another’s arguments. Instead, prodded by talk radio and Fox News, we approach argument as a game of sides, easily drifting online into name calling, factual errors, or dubious sourcing—or not encountering contrary positions by choice.
Young people often no longer have regular mainstream news habits. Indeed, they follow a pattern of “news finds me” through what comedians make fun of, or what friends send through social media links.
From the perspective of a half-century of writing guest columns, I must refrain from seeing all change as bad. I really don’t aspire to return to card catalogues, electric typewriters, and Liquid Paper. We have great tools for research, composition, and distribution. The challenge is to use them with more intellectual rigor.
Starting tomorrow, the next four years will be a disturbing challenge. Trump and his acolytes have shown little devotion to accuracy, logic, consistency, coherence, or even democratic processes. We will get by only if we stand true to the best qualities of a vibrant editorial/opinion page. We must insist on accuracy, logic, and courageous reporting. We must not be afraid to be critical. Finally, we must teach these skills to succeeding generations. The skills are as timeless as they are vital.
|
|
Discussing:
- Hail, Caesar! (1 reply)
- Trump: U.S. takeover of Gaza Strip, "Riviera of the Middle East" (2 replies)
- U.S. Treasury Dept. data breach? (1 reply)
- Let them eat cake... (2 replies)
- How an arcane Treasury Department office became ground zero in the war over federal spending (6 replies)
- TN Voucher bill contracts with Arkansas reject (1 reply)
- Are Meta/Zuckerberg paying a bribe? (3 replies)
- Plane crash in the Potomac (3 replies)
- Maryville Jan. 6 felon, pardoned, faces sentencing for conspiracy to murder federal employees conviction (3 replies)
- Google Maps will change the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America (2 replies)
- Bridgestone closes a tire plant in Tennessee with 700 layoffs and other reductions (2 replies)
- If illegal immigrants are freeloaders.... (1 reply)
TN Progressive
- It's Time to Call For the Arrest of Elon Musk! (RoaneViews)
- Books (RoaneViews)
- Tennessee Legislature...Theme Park or Rocky Horror? (RoaneViews)
- Sunday Sermon (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- Lee's Fried Chicken in Alcoa closed (BlountViews)
- Alcoa, Hall Rd. Corridor Study meeting, July 30, 2024 (BlountViews)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
- July 4, 2024 - aka The Twilight Zone (Joe Powell)
- Chef steals food to serve at restaurant? (BlountViews)
- Blount County, TDOT make road deal for gun mfg ignoring town of Louisville,TN, (BlountViews)
- Winter at the Big Rocks (Whitescreek Journal)
TN Politics
- U.S. Department of Justice backs out of Tennessee transgender care case (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee speaker’s bill would defund local governments for violating state law (TN Lookout)
- Stockard on the Stump: Old hands, not dark money, push vouchers to passage (TN Lookout)
- U.S. Senate confirms Russ Vought, a Project 2025 author, to manage the nation’s budget (TN Lookout)
- Seattle judge is second to indefinitely block Trump’s birthright citizenship order (TN Lookout)
- “A horrible idea”; under a new law, older teens charged with murder will be tried as adults (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Breaking: Knox schools to close Monday-Tuesday (Knox TN Today)
- Lady Vols upset No. 5 UConn for signature win (Knox TN Today)
- Tennyson, RSV and horses (Knox TN Today)
- ‘How Baking Soda Helped Save Our Birds’ (Knox TN Today)
- Elite Chance Frye: Special match, special cousin, special community (Knox TN Today)
- Authentic Mexican fare at Mariscos Pacifico Nayarit (Knox TN Today)
- Knox the Fox shares James Beard Award semifinalists (Knox TN Today)
- Service highlight: Paws to Visit (Knox TN Today)
- Zakai Zeigler to visit Food City Deane Hill (Knox TN Today)
- Fast-Charging program moving ahead in Tennessee (Knox TN Today)
- Badger goes cold to find his waterfall (Knox TN Today)
- Sphere weather (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Megan Boswell Trial Day 3 | Defense questions evidence after prosecution shows edited text exchange (WBIR)
- 'It's pretty devastating': Morgan County mourns lives lost as tornado recovery efforts begin (WATE)
- 'Something I will never forget': Morgan County resident recounts tornado (WATE)
- Sevierville PD sued over seizure of legal hemp thought to be marijuana (WATE)
- How to help those impacted by deadly tornado in Morgan County (WATE)
- TN convict pleads guilty to 2013 killing of Knoxville woman whose body has never been found (WBIR)
- Karns teacher on paid leave after backlash over social media posts (WATE)
- Late 2026 opening date targeted for new Andrew Johnson Building hotel (WATE)
- Here are the 14 Big Lots stores staying open in Tennessee (WBIR)
- Heart of the Matter: Blount County Sheriff James Berrong (WBIR)
- KCS naming facilities committee to consider naming Gibbs High School baseball field after Morgan Wallen (WBIR)
- Sevierville releases statement after 'comments, emails and phone calls' targeting city staff over RV dealer's overly-tall flagpole (WBIR)
News Sentinel
State News
- Bill would ban most popular hemp products in Tennessee - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- The Rant - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Chattanooga’s Moon River festival canceled for second year - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Dear Abby: Man’s delusions put brother in a difficult spot - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Crews rush to recover commuter plane found crashed on Alaska sea ice before expected snow and wind - The Associated Press (US News)
- Judge pauses Trump order to put USAID employees on administrative leave - NPR (US News)
- Trump Says He Will Install Himself as Kennedy Center Chairman - The New York Times (US News)
- Trump signs executive order targeting South Africa over land law - BBC.com (US News)
- Musk’s team takes control of key systems at Consumer Financial Protection Bureau - NPR (Business)
- Donald Trump revokes Joe Biden’s security clearance in latest revenge move - The Guardian US (US News)
- Trump Administration Move to Freeze E.V. Charger Funding Confounds States - The New York Times (Business)
- United States-Japan Joint Leaders’ Statement - The White House (US News)
- Trump pauses tariffs on millions of low-value packages from China - The Associated Press (Business)
- Senate prepares to blow past Mike Johnson on Trump's reconciliation bill - Axios (US News)
- Beauty stocks post major losses after a week of worrying results - CNBC (Business)
- Stock Market Today: Dow Jones Sinks, But Nasdaq Hit Harder; Uber Gets Ackman Lift (Live Coverage) - Investor's Business Daily (Business)
- Trump says Japan's Nippon Steel will now invest in U.S. Steel — not take it over - NPR (Business)
- US economy created 143,000 jobs in January - Financial Times (Business)
- Elon Musk’s DOGE Is Heading to the Pentagon. Defense Stocks Are Falling. - Barron's (US News)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
Good luck with that.
There hasn't been a market for truth in quite some time. Terrorism and Nazi style government is the flavor of the day. Enough of you and the peasants demands of freedom. The media overlords determine what can be said.
There's no room anymore for pieces like this. Where do you go?
I came down the mountain with my tail between my legs right after Thanksgiving. Despite working toward the goal of being able to spend the winter off the grid, I was nowhere close. I figured, ah, what the hell, I'll just play bridge as hard as I can and focus and see what happens. Promptly got blackballed. I'm still not sure what the hell even happened. But, that idea was shot down day one.
I'd hooked up with my oldest best friend again, a lifelong relationship that has taken intermittent breaks of up to a decade. His wife was passing through to help with the horse caravans take supplies to the flood victims in North Carolina. She was an on ground volunteer. You don't think about volunteering for this kind of disaster relief as ongoing, but it is and the longer something goes on, the harder it is to get volunteers. So there was plenty of work and Bonnie was spending her early retirement years doing something she valued. Paul is an usher at the VIP elevator in Lambeau Stadium. It's a dream job. Paul and I went off to Lambeau on a vacation a couple years ago and ended up at Shenanigans, Fuzzy Thurston's old bar and the gossip surrounding the quarterback was absolutely bizarre. Seems like there was a limo driver that heard it all. In reality, nobody liked Lindy Infante's offense. There's nothing like gossip in a Wisconsin dive. Except maybe a meat raffle.
So as a result of boredom more than anything, but inspired by Bonnie's volunteer effort (We were all raised Lutheran. More on that later) decided to take some coffee to the Methodists for their warming center. I would have taken it to the Lutherans if they were doing anything, but they weren't. They did open their doors for the election public forums, but not this. They didn't give us coffee though, which I would have gladly brought. Plus somebody had published a wish list for the warming centers and staying home with a fire is easy on the budget and we'd already paid for the room to meet Paul and Bonnie at Ft. Walton Beach this past weekend. We'd talked about staying til Wednesday, if we had, we'd still be there now. I did get pictures of their snow plows to to show I'm not the ignorant fool and liar Glenn Jacobs people keep trying to make me out to be. Other communities DO respond to emergency weather conditions with rentals and planning, two things we still don't do. Well, there was a plan, but it was only a plan for about half the days we've had so far.
So, I'm at Costco, pulling stuff from the wish list and taking it to Magnolia Avenue United Methodist Church (UMC). Now, I'm not Methodist and I no longer do church. To me, church is a place of philosophical, intellectual and spiritual community. Most churches want buy-in rather than exploration of philosophical and intellectual aspects and they're just not for me. Trout fishing does that for me. So, I'm pulling my donation, really just killing time until the roads back up to Green Cove and my place melt, spending money I couldn't fish with anyway, and it occurred to me that what was being attempted, even at this relatively small level, was an expensive, labor intensive endeavor. Opening a warming center is not a cheap endeavor to be taken lightly.
So I go to Magnolia Ave. UMC (2700 East Magnolia Ave. Knoxville, Tn. 37914) to drop off the supplies. I met a couple folks that were helping. This was right around the 3rd, as I recall, and everyone, including me, seemed to think this would be in the rear view mirror in a couple weeks. It was before anything hit the fan. The goal was no deaths, and everyone thought that was attainable, best I could tell. Three weeks later, we're looking forward to seasonably cold weather, which is what we were preparing for to begin with. We've lost three people. Three human beings to a diverse set of circumstances. And instead of recognizing and coming up with short term solutions to these circumstances, the way we as a community are responding involves either denial or blame. Neither of those approaches solves problems.
As a result of my first trip to Magnolia Ave UMC, I made it a point to take study to the weather response plan, something I'd researched rather deeply after last year, as it related to warming the homeless during subfreezing weather events. As it turns out, when you plan for normal weather and normal deviations, when a record cold spell hits the plan is inadequate. Go figure. Regardless of other flaws and inadequacies, the plan's scope and needs were always going to be inadequate. That's how these things work. In specific areas of planning, these inadequacies can prove to be dramatic. They can expose errors rather quickly. In the case of this plan, it only went to the point of a State of Emergency, at which point there seems to have been some sort of presumption that the resources freed to whoever was in charge of that emergency response would be used to lesson the effects of the emergency. That power lies in the office of the County Mayor. That help never came. That's how this chain of command works. Blame who you want.
My second trip, I asked if either Tim or Kecia was there. Kecia had sent me a friend request, presumably because of my work. I was quite honored. Tim is sort of a whirling dervish, and as a result of pure chance met me and showed me around. First off, I couldn't believe they were pulling off this task. I'm asking questions and he's shooting answers from the hip and he doesn't even have a working heating unit and I'm staring at a half million to get it started restoration job and it occurred to me that if we wanted this guy and gal to operate in our community, and we do, believe me, we should get them some resources. They're mentoring and providing training to young folks. They're helping people that would be falling through the cracks. Plus, operational basics you need to run a church with that sort of mission. They need bathroom upgrades, including another couple showers. They are emergency response front liners. There is but one rule, keep the peace. It's a sanctuary of God and that is the human condition upon entry. Seemed like a pretty good idea to me, I was surprised I'd never heard it before. They need a laundry room. No telling what kind of shape the roof is in or what the utility bill will be. They have , and need, a commercial kitchen. They will cook whatever food they have with whatever trained volunteers they have. But, having worked in a commercial kitchen 50 years ago, I was concerned about how familiar all the equipment seemed to look. I have no idea what that kind of upgrade costs. So I asked Tim how much money he needed and he started talking about a heater and I asked if a half a million would get him started and he said yes and that's what I'm doing here. Honestly, he probably needs three times that, but he strikes me as resourceful, and I did spend 26 years learning to size people up in less than 15 seconds. You'd be surprised how good I am at it.
So I head out thinking, once again, who could possibly be against this? It's like I think I'm living in a Voltaire play. Come to find out, everyone wants to decide who should pay for this and who should be in charge, and everyone is blaming Indya Kincannan except Tim and Kecia. It's the old Sam Kinison routine but it very much fits a modern ministry. Hungry kid? Do you want to fill out a form or make the kid a sandwich? It's the reality of a ministry with a committed mission in the times we live in. And the reality is, the mission of Magnolia Ave UMC as well as their sister Vestal UMC is expanding. And it's a service mission serving those who might otherwise be alone without help. It's kind of the whole point of the Christian Philosophy, when you get right down to it. But they don't want government money. They are a sanctuary. They don't wish to betray the trust of those they serve. So the donations need to be from the private sector to go to the ministry. What I honestly recommend doing, is buying a giant box of tampons and drop them off for their women's programs and clinics and asking whoever you give them to to answer your questions and show you around. Don't expect details of the operation. Read the audience. I always like to help out or volunteer in person before I jump in whole hog. I suspect quite a few volunteers showed up and were trained. A hope at least some continue. Which brings us back to where do we get a half million seed money?
Us. The community. Historically, the Presbyterians and Methodists pioneered this region, bringing the teachings of Calvin and Wesley to the region. We've always been a stronghold for those community values. As the Baptists became more prominent their outreach extended into the community. There is a reason we became known as volunteers. When we were needed by our people, we responded. I like to think we have some of those values left. So, I'm going to leave this here for now, still not having a clue about raising a half million dollars. How do you raise money that will go directly to helping people these days?