The Supreme Court begins a new term, and resumes its trashing of American legal traditions, the first Monday in October. That should remind us of the stakes in the upcoming election, but it’s also a time to recall how we got to our Clarence Thomas problem. He has been a Supreme Court justice for nearly 33 years, longer than the two dozen years of service from the man he was nominated to replace, Thurgood Marshall. The late justice Marshall was a pillar of judicial integrity, a champion for civil rights, and an accomplished jurist. Thomas does not measure up on those criteria—and over time has become what many of us feared at the time of his nomination, a bitter advocate for ill-informed retrograde policies and an embarrassment to the court.
continued...
Thurgood Marshall’s rise to the Supreme Court is an American success story. As an attorney, he argued 32 civil rights cases before the Court, winning 29 of them. He was nominated to the U.S. Court of Appeals and authored 98 majority opinions, none overturned by the Supreme Court. He served briefly as U. S. Solicitor General before being nominated to the nation’s top court. Despite flak from some Southern Senators, he was confirmed by a Senate vote of 69 to 11, with 20 not voting.
As he retired, Marshall warned then President George Herbert Walker Bush about using skin color as an excuse to “pick the wrong Negro…There’s no difference between a white snake and a black snake; they’ll both bite.” Shortly thereafter, Bush nominated Clarence Thomas, and our nation has suffered from that poor choice.
Thomas did not get corporate law offers when he graduated Yale Law School, and his resentment for that is palpable. So, he took a political route, becoming a staff lawyer to Missouri’s Attorney General John Danforth, following him to Washington when Danforth became a U.S. Senator. Veteran filmmaker Michael Kirk, who produced a documentary for PBS’s Frontline about Thomas explained what happened next to the NPR program Fresh Air:
“And one person tells us that he tries to join the conservative Reagan revolution because the line is shorter for Black people on that side, on the Republican side. Over on the Democratic side, lots of Black people in line to get good jobs, but in the conservative Republican world, Clarence Thomas - if he joins that line, it's a very short line. And he does do that. And he is rewarded by the Reagan administration for his willingness to step up and defend Reagan. Whenever Reagan would be called racist or whenever a policy might be called racist, it is Clarence Thomas who they put forward performing the task of defender of Reagan's racial equality instincts.”
Thomas moved into an eight-year stint leading the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Kirk reports that while there he was something of an abusive bully, especially toward other black people. “The way they [EEOC staffers] tell the story,” said Kirk, “he's trying to appeal to the white Reagan staffers and conservatives by being the Black guy who's the first to tell a kind of racially tinted joke or use an unkind phrase, proving to them that he can be trusted.”
People remember the dramatic Anita Hill testimony about Thomas’ crude sexually abusive behavior. Two things that aren’t remembered as well are a damning similar account from uncalled witness Angela Wright (her account corroborated by another coworker), and the low opinion of Thomas from the American Bar Association.
The ABA ranks court nominees as: Well Qualified, Qualified, or Not Qualified. A review of the current Supreme Court members is quite instructive. The ABA’s Standing Committee on the Judiciary unanimously rated as Well Qualified the nominations of Neil Gorsuch, Sonia Sotomayor, Ketanji Brown Jackson, John Roberts, Brett Kavanaugh, and Elena Kagan. Samuel Alito scored Well Qualified with one recusal. Amy Coney Barrett received a majority voted for Well Qualified with a minority scoring Qualified. Clarence Thomas trails all of them with a majority giving a lackluster Qualified, and a minority of the panel scoring him Not Qualified, with one recusal.
The Senate failed its duty, approving Thomas 52 to 48.
Thomas spent much of his early time on the Court as a silent presence on the bench, routinely concurring in the opinions of Antonin Scalia. Thomas returned the favor from the elder President Bush by helping his son rise to the presidency courtesy of the infamous Bush v. Gore ruling. One comedian joked that the younger Bush won the election by getting 100% of the black vote (showing an image of Clarence Thomas).
The blatant politics and dubious reasoning of Bush v. Gore started the downward slide in public esteem for the Supreme Court. That slide grew to a plummet when Thomas was in the majority taking away a federally recognized constitutional right to an abortion.
Thomas wants to go even further. He has written about also revisiting marriage equality, protected access to contraception, and even the actual malice standard protecting journalists from libel suits designed to chill vibrant public debate.
Further damaging the reputation of the Court have been Thomas’ routine acceptance luxurious trips and other perks from wealthy benefactors. Other justices have had some lapses in this regard (and Alito’s bizarre flag flaps merit recusal), but Thomas excels at flaunting ethics rules. Pro Publica has exposed the Thomas excesses, and reports they likely tally into the millions of dollars.
Thus, we remain stuck with the kind of snake-like wrong choice that Thurgood Marshall feared.
Mark Harmon is a professor of journalism and media at the University of Tennessee.
|
|
Discussing:
- Trump: U.S. takeover of Gaza Strip, "Riviera of the Middle East" (2 replies)
- U.S. Treasury Dept. data breach? (1 reply)
- Let them eat cake... (2 replies)
- How an arcane Treasury Department office became ground zero in the war over federal spending (6 replies)
- TN Voucher bill contracts with Arkansas reject (1 reply)
- Are Meta/Zuckerberg paying a bribe? (3 replies)
- Plane crash in the Potomac (3 replies)
- Maryville Jan. 6 felon, pardoned, faces sentencing for conspiracy to murder federal employees conviction (3 replies)
- Google Maps will change the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America (2 replies)
- Bridgestone closes a tire plant in Tennessee with 700 layoffs and other reductions (2 replies)
- If illegal immigrants are freeloaders.... (1 reply)
- Tim, Tim, Tim...Sigh... (1 reply)
TN Progressive
- It's Time to Call For the Arrest of Elon Musk! (RoaneViews)
- Books (RoaneViews)
- Tennessee Legislature...Theme Park or Rocky Horror? (RoaneViews)
- Sunday Sermon (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- Lee's Fried Chicken in Alcoa closed (BlountViews)
- Alcoa, Hall Rd. Corridor Study meeting, July 30, 2024 (BlountViews)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
- July 4, 2024 - aka The Twilight Zone (Joe Powell)
- Chef steals food to serve at restaurant? (BlountViews)
- Blount County, TDOT make road deal for gun mfg ignoring town of Louisville,TN, (BlountViews)
- Winter at the Big Rocks (Whitescreek Journal)
TN Politics
- Tennessee speaker’s bill would defund local governments for violating state law (TN Lookout)
- Stockard on the Stump: Old hands, not dark money, push vouchers to passage (TN Lookout)
- U.S. Senate confirms Russ Vought, a Project 2025 author, to manage the nation’s budget (TN Lookout)
- Seattle judge is second to indefinitely block Trump’s birthright citizenship order (TN Lookout)
- “A horrible idea”; under a new law, older teens charged with murder will be tried as adults (TN Lookout)
- Lawmakers press Social Security on lag in paying expanded benefits to public employees (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Breaking: Knox schools to close Monday-Tuesday (Knox TN Today)
- Lady Vols upset No. 5 UConn for signature win (Knox TN Today)
- Tennyson, RSV and horses (Knox TN Today)
- ‘How Baking Soda Helped Save Our Birds’ (Knox TN Today)
- Elite Chance Frye: Special match, special cousin, special community (Knox TN Today)
- Authentic Mexican fare at Mariscos Pacifico Nayarit (Knox TN Today)
- Knox the Fox shares James Beard Award semifinalists (Knox TN Today)
- Service highlight: Paws to Visit (Knox TN Today)
- Zakai Zeigler to visit Food City Deane Hill (Knox TN Today)
- Fast-Charging program moving ahead in Tennessee (Knox TN Today)
- Badger goes cold to find his waterfall (Knox TN Today)
- Sphere weather (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- NWS ranks fatal Morgan County tornado as EF-2 preliminarily (WBIR)
- Megan Boswell Trial Day 3 | Defense questions evidence after prosecution shows edited text exchange (WBIR)
- Knox County Schools Board of Education approves new K-8 school (WATE)
- EF-2 tornado confirmed in Morgan County by National Weather Service (WATE)
- National Weather Service confirms tornado touched down Grainger County (WATE)
- Here are the 14 Big Lots stores staying open in Tennessee (WBIR)
- PHOTOS: Severe storms cause damage in East Tennessee (WATE)
- Heart of the Matter: Blount County Sheriff James Berrong (WBIR)
- Mother, daughter dead, others injured after tornado in Morgan County (WATE)
- Rep. Tim Burchett questions UT System President about 'UTK Furry Club' (WATE)
- KCS naming facilities committee to consider naming Gibbs High School baseball field after Morgan Wallen (WBIR)
- Sevierville releases statement after 'comments, emails and phone calls' targeting city staff over RV dealer's overly-tall flagpole (WBIR)
News Sentinel
State News
- Bill would ban most popular hemp products in Tennessee - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Dear Abby: Man’s delusions put brother in a difficult spot - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- James Willis Adams Obituary - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- First-quarter struggles doom UTC women vs. UNC Greensboro - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Trump tells Ishiba at the White House that he wants to slash the US trade deficit with Japan - The Associated Press (US News)
- Searchers in Alaska scour frozen tundra and icy seas for missing plane with 10 aboard - The Associated Press (US News)
- Trump administration suspends $5bn electric vehicle charging program - The Guardian US (Business)
- Trump delays tariffs on small packages from China - BBC.com (Business)
- Trump says he will announce reciprocal tariffs on many countries next week - Reuters (US News)
- DOJ agrees to give two-days’ notice if it releases names of FBI employees who worked on January 6 cases - CNN (US News)
- Stock Market Mixed Amid Trump Tariff Fears: Weekly Review - Investor's Business Daily (Business)
- How Many Federal Worker Resignations Would Be a Lot? - The New York Times (US News)
- Trump considering allowing sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon Steel - CBS News (Business)
- Not 1. Not 2. Not 3. Not 4. 5 winter storms could deliver more snow than the last two winters combined - CNN (US News)
- White House calls mixed jobs numbers 'weak,' blames Biden - CNBC (Business)
- Nvidia Stock Is Climbing. Amazon’s Earnings Were a Big Moment for the Chip Maker. - Barron's (Business)
- US updates: ICC says it is undeterred by Trump sanctions - DW (English) (US News)
- ‘Constitutional emergency’: senior US Democrat demands inquiry into Musk’s government blitz - The Guardian US (US News)
- State Farm Was All In on California—Until It Pulled the Plug Before the Fires - The Wall Street Journal (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South