Mon
Mar 7 2011
08:35 am
I was really disappointed and angry when I heard WUOT this morning. It's like Jessel was handed the script from Karl Rove:
"Thousands of rally-ers from both sides" were in Nashville Saturday.
continued...
There almost NO tea puppets compared to the overwhelming turnout by teachers.
The entire report was terribly slanted toward making the tea party seem worthy and no one who listened would understand that the tea partiers were outnumbered ten to one by even the most favorable count.
|
|
Discussing:
- Natural gas cost nearly double from a year ago (2 replies)
- Many in Nashville still without power (2 replies)
- Snow! Again. Maybe. (1 reply)
- President & Mrs. Obama: a wake-up call to every American (3 replies)
- Are you snow ready? (2 replies)
- Geographic Clarification (1 reply)
- Small dam in Walland to be removed (2 replies)
- Embarrassed? (1 reply)
- Feds looking for West Knox detention location? (6 replies)
- Search for Mike Johnson's Spine (2 replies)
- Trump says his 'own morality' is limit to his global power (3 replies)
- Pentagon seeks to reduce Sen. Mark Kelly's retirement rank over video urging troops to refuse illegal orders (2 replies)
TN Progressive
- Alcoa Safe Streets Plan Survey (BlountViews)
- WATCH THIS SPACE. (Left Wing Cracker)
- Report on Blount County, TN, No Kings event (BlountViews)
- America As It Is Right Now (RoaneViews)
- A friend sent this: From Captain McElwee's Tall Tales of Roane County (RoaneViews)
- The Meidas Touch (RoaneViews)
- Massive Security Breach Analysis (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- Lee's Fried Chicken in Alcoa closed (BlountViews)
- Alcoa, Hall Rd. Corridor Study meeting, July 30, 2024 (BlountViews)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
- July 4, 2024 - aka The Twilight Zone (Joe Powell)
TN Politics
- Federal judge blocks Pentagon attempt to demote Sen. Mark Kelly over illegal orders video (TN Lookout)
- Knoxville attorney withdraws from Appeals Court quest amid partisan politics (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee Republicans advance bills targeting LGBTQ+ residents (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee bill creating immigration crime clears first hurdle (TN Lookout)
- Shutdown looms for FEMA, Coast Guard, TSA with stalemate over Homeland Security funds (TN Lookout)
- US House approves bill mandating proof of citizenship for voting in federal elections (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Tale of Two Proposals (Knox TN Today)
- Patience and adventure: Capturing winter sunrise on Roan Mountain (Knox TN Today)
- Who is skating this week at the Olympics? (Knox TN Today)
- Vols blow another big lead but beat Bulldogs, 73-64 (Knox TN Today)
- Duane Grieve + ET Design Center + Anderson County business leaders ++ (Knox TN Today)
- Knoxville Writers Guild announces Nia Thompson as 2026 Youth Poet Laureate (Knox TN Today)
- Last week’s high amounts of snow didn’t hamper high property sales (Knox TN Today)
- Won’t you be my neighbor? -Fred Rogers (Knox TN Today)
- Weekend Scene starts today from Cabaret to Galentine’s fun (Knox TN Today)
- HEADLINES: News and events from the World, the USA, Tennessee, Knox & Historic Notes (Knox TN Today)
- Vaughn Pharmacy, trusted hometown pharmacy (Knox TN Today)
- Knoxville Youth Orchestra performs free concert tonight (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Knox County mayoral race gets 1st Democratic candidate in labor leader Beau Hawk (WATE)
- 5 pounds of jalapenos tossed during inspection at Mexican restaurant in LaFollette (WATE)
- Joey Aguilar's legal team files new brief in NCAA case (WATE)
- TDOT storm recovery crews at risk on Tennessee highways (WATE)
- Knoxville's Sunshine Services launches fundraiser to support workers before program closes (WATE)
- Famous Zoo Knoxville African grey parrot 'Einstein' dies after cancer battle (WATE)
News Sentinel
State News
- Chattanooga accountant Jonathan Frost free on $10K bond after pleading guilty - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- New TVA board under Trump extends coal, eliminates renewable energy as priority - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- TVA reverses course on retiring two largest coal plants, documents show - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Former NFL player arrested on murder charges in Ooltewah - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Federal court blocks Hegseth effort to punish Democratic senator - Politico (US News)
- Border czar hails a ‘safer’ Minnesota as he says the state’s immigration crackdown is over - AP News (US News)
- Partial government shutdown looms as ICE negotiations hit stalemate - The Washington Post (US News)
- Nancy Guthrie disappearance: Investigators find a set of gloves along road as search enters 12th day - Fox News (US News)
- Trump revokes EPA finding on greenhouse gas threat in huge blow to climate change regulations - CNBC (US News)
- US stocks fall sharply as tech sell-off resumes - Financial Times (Business)
- Spirit Airlines sells more planes, calls back 500 flight attendants from furlough ahead of spring break - CNBC (Business)
- Home sales plunge despite affordability improving - Axios (Business)
- Author of viral 'Something Big is Coming' essay says AI helped him write it — and that proves his point - Business Insider (Business)
- Culver City mayor responds to Bondi's comments during fiery Capitol Hill hearing - ABC7 Los Angeles (US News)
- "He Sounds Nervous": American Airlines CEO Robert Isom Responds To Union Revolt—Here's His Turnaround Plan - View from the Wing (Business)
- Some folks on Wall Street think yesterday’s U.S. jobs number is ‘implausible’ and thus due for a downward correction - Fortune (Business)
- Forbes 250: America’s Greatest Historic Innovators - Forbes (Business)
- In Kentucky, People Blame Ford More Than Trump for Lost Factory Jobs - The New York Times (Business)
- Exclusive: AeroVironment's LOCUST counter-drone laser used by US Army near El Paso airport, sources say - Reuters (US News)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South

*
Did Jessel indicate whether she attended the rally personally or did she possibly regurgitate that sole AP story containing the aberrant "headcount?"
If she wasn't there in the flesh, her report is indicative of this problem I predicted Sunday--namely that the more favorable "headcounts" collected by ALL Nashville-area media outlets might get buried, while the single AP story might get wider circulation.
So...was she there???
Let's ask her
There were two interviews one tea partier and one teacher. to be fair there should have been TEN teachers interviewed.
newsroom@wuot.org
both sides?
So...were you there???
Or are you just banking on a news story or internet blog that contains the aberrant “headcount” that suits your agenda.
My Reporter was there in person
We have the video. has anyone seen the video of the tea puppet rally by any chance? I only have photos of three or four people on that side.
Go away troll.
Go away troll.
*
Did you direct this comment to me, Absolan?
If so, I was referring to the fact that ALL Nashville-area media outlets, without exception, offered estimates of the TEA "headcount" at 3000 to 5000.
Presumably, those Nashville-area media were able to send a reporter down the street to attend.
In contrast, it was ONLY the lone AP story that offered a TEA "headcount" of 1000--a volume of attendees 1/3 to 1/5 as many.
It's certainly true that the higher "headcount" offered by those local media outlets "suits my agenda."
What possible reason, though, do you suggest for this single, abherrant report--and why should any of us rely on that report, rather than on all the others?
State your case, already.
Found this interesting video
Watch this and note that the shots of the big crowds are of the Teachers not the tea puppets. Another case of dishonest coverage? A pan of the actual tea party rally at the end shows how few they actually were.
(link...)
Accurate information is not hard to find
I went to YouTube last night and watched several videos of the demonstrations.
There was even one teabagger video exclaiming how large the TEA crowds were.
No excuses for her shoddy reporting of the event.
Her teabagger interviewee was allowed to give the very well rehearsed talking point with no chance for rebuttal from anyone for the crap he spewed.
Sickening.
I think dishonest is too
I think dishonest is too strong of a characterization...at worst the writing needed to be a bit more clear. There were thousands of rally-ers, and they were from both sides. Who outnumbered whom was not germain to the report, which included both sides of the issue, if we're talking about the same wuot and the same report. Granted, the wording did not make clear which group was larger, but I certainly didn't get the impression that Jessel was implying there were thousands of TEA members and thousands of tea-baggers. I think this is a hyper-sensitive issue, and no report, no matter how balanced, will make either side happy.
I got the impression she was there, b/c there were soundbites used. Fwiw.
False equivalence
It is relevant. One of the biggest problems of modern journalism is the creation of false equivalences in a misdirected effort to be neutral. For some inexplicable reason, reporters believe that the best way to cover a controversy is to let a representative from both sides have their say, and with no fact-checking or review, expect the readers, listeners and viewers decide for themselves where the truth lies.
The better approach would be to present a clear picture of who was there, what they were saying, and offer a dispassionate review of the truth and/or distortions presented by each side.
Consider this: in the middle of a rainstorm, you could find a thousand people with umbrellas up and any number of meteorologists who can confirm the precipitation. You might also be able to find one guy in a windowless cubicle inside a building who will insist that it's not raining at all. If you're reporting the rain event, do you give the guy in the cubicle equal time, and fail to point out that he can't see the weather outside and is thus likely misinformed? I think not. Seeking the truth should be the goal, not passive neutrality.
Quick aside...
Somebody, I sure am growing fond of your posts here.
Your're the most polite, articulate, well-reasoned ANONYMOUS poster I think I've ever met on any blog.
Thanks for your continued contributions.
For some inexplicable reason,
For some inexplicable reason, reporters believe that the best way to cover a controversy is to let a representative from both sides have their say, and with no fact-checking or review, expect the readers, listeners and viewers decide for themselves where the truth lies.
This has been EXACTLY my problem with the KNS coverage of Hillside/Ridgetop (except that they've quoted way more opponents than supporters).
And yes, this is my current hobby horse. I've been riding it since November and I expect I will ride it till things change (supposedly, on 3/13, when the KNS says it will publish an "in depth" story on Hillside/Ridgetop).
Both sides did NOT have "thousands"
But that was the impression you would get if all you knew was Jessel's report. You can trade "dishonest" for "incompetently deceptive" if you wish but the fact remains that the report misleads the listener.
This is the exact same tactic that plays one statement from one global warming affirming climate scientist and one statement from one climate change denier. There should be 400 statements from affirming scientists to every one statement from a denier.
*
Say what?!
The whole purpose of the rally, for either group, was to indicate to legislators the volume of support for that group's position.
Of course it's "germaine" to ask which group's size effectively demonstrated greater support.
What do you think a rally IS?!
Clear up confusion?
First, let me deflect some of the criticism targeted toward Christine Jessel and focus it on the responsible party. The reference to "thousands representing both sides of the issue" (the exact wording) was not part of her report-- rather, it was part of my introduction to her report. I will admit, in retrospect, that the verbiage was ambiguous, but I would discourage you from reading any heinous intent into it. It was, as an earlier poster said, poor writing. I apologize for any confusion.
And yes, she was there. Getting very wet.
The report left a factually dishonest impression
Both in the introduction and the main body. Heinous or incompetent, the effect is the same. I expect such from Fox channels but it is heartbreaking to see this from NPR and PBS.
Will WUOT take steps to correct this particular instance?
Let's note that WUOT was not the only news outlet to engage in either sloppy reporting or out right intentionally dishonest reporting. The channel 5 piece is just one case in point showing the tea puppet flag with the teachers' rally as the backdrop. There were several others.
Exactly
Will WUOT take steps to correct the report? Mistakes happen. We all know this and can sympathize with that. However, the real issue is what steps will be taken to ensure that listeners to 'All Things Considered' do not walk away with the impression of a false equivalence. At the national level, NPR News has been abysmal on so many issues that its hard for me to fight for its survival against yet another Republican assault on its funding. There's only so many times that I can hear Guy Raz tell me that Social Security is just going to have to be on the chopping block before I walk away in disgust.
Where is the WUOT correction?
I listened this morning for one hour to 'The Morning Edition' and heard nothing. Anyone else?
Sounds like some emails are
Sounds like some emails are in order... I'll wait until others respond before doing so. I'm on Spring Break, so I was happily sleeping this morning. God knows that I hate my alarm clock!
*
Thanks, Matt, for that clarification and I choose to believe that there was no "heinous intent" in your introduction.
I do think, though, that WUOT should offer a retraction of the intro stating there were "thousands representing both sides of the issue."
In all the reporting I was able to review Sunday (that was 8 or so print and/or broadcast reports), only one offered any concrete number as to how many Tea Partiers were there and it said "about 350."
In the absence of any info to the contrary, I think you'll admit that that's a far cry from "thousands," so I trust you'll also understand my polite request for a correction on WUOT's part?
Thanks again for your candor and your willingness to accept personal responsibility for the error.
The thing that's
The thing that's disappointing about this and the AP report that the News Sentinel ran is that the tea baggers' puppet masters own the governor's office, the house, the senate, the means of production and the media. But that's not enough. They want to own the message, too. And public schools.
But they don't own the streets of Nashville. This was a day about teachers and their rights, and about protecting public education from corporate takeover. This was their day. Responsible media outlets reported it that way.
No report should have given more than a passing reference that a few tea baggers showed up but weren't really a factor, and certainly shouldn't have given them a platform to promote mass ignorance as the AP report did.
And the notion of presenting "both sides" and calling it "objective" is, as noted above, anything but. I don't think it's going to fly any more. There are too many other sources of information from too many people willing and able to call them out.
People are starting to wake up from the Faux News induced coma and they are taking to the streets.
A proper lede
"Thousands of teachers and hundreds of tea party members gathered for separate rallies at the state capitol Saturday, despite the heavy rain."
(link...)
good journalism
It is great to hear that people are demanding better journalism. That is a good thing. Good journalism serves everyone's best interest.
It is interesting to note that for some people this need only happened when their ox got gored. They were very happy when the slanted advocacy went their way. Quite ironic to see some of the most noted defenders of the Sentinel change their minds on the issue and demand fair reporting.
Straw man alert!
This group is pretty even handed in its praise and criticism. I'm on record praising and criticizing KNS. The (KNS)piece referred to in this thread was beyond contempt, ergo the criticism.
*
He isn't needling you, WC, he's needling me.
Cafkia and I were asked to participate in a KNS readers' "focus group" five or so years back (as I know RNeal and cjensen and several others posting here have been), so MM here has been groping his mailbox in search of his own invite ever since.
Just never got over it, I guess...
turnout
This is the second paragraph of the AP story KNS posted about the protest:
"A few hundred tea party supporters gathered on the statehouse steps to call on Republican leadership to pass the measure, while more than 1,000 supporters of the Tennessee Education Association, the state's largest teachers union, marched to the Legislative Plaza across the street to speak out against the bill."
Note that is says the tea party had "a few hundred" and the TEA supporters had "more than 1,000" present. That shows the relative turnout based on the reporter's observations.